Striking off vs liquidating a company
Two ways to close a company, with different costs, tax outcomes and risks, and one question that decides between them.
Closing a company is not just a matter of stopping trading. The company still exists on the register until it is removed, and it still has debts, tax and filings. There are two main routes for closing a solvent company: applying to be struck off, and members' voluntary liquidation. Insolvent companies follow a different route. This guide sets out the options, the tax treatment and how to decide.
The first question: is the company solvent?
A solvent company can pay all its debts. An insolvent company cannot. The answer to this question determines which routes are available.
| Situation | Usual route |
|---|---|
| Solvent, with no or modest assets | Strike off |
| Solvent, with significant assets to distribute | Members' voluntary liquidation |
| Insolvent, directors want to close it in an orderly way | Creditors' voluntary liquidation |
| Insolvent, creditors take action | Compulsory liquidation |
If you are not sure whether the company is solvent, take advice before choosing a route. Using strike off to avoid debts is a serious mistake.
Striking off
A voluntary strike off is the simplest and cheapest route. The directors apply to Companies House to have the company removed from the register.
Conditions
The company must not, in the previous three months, have traded, changed its name, disposed of property or rights for value, or engaged in any other activity outside the normal course of closing down. It must not be subject to insolvency proceedings or a scheme with creditors.
The process
- Stop trading and settle debts. Pay creditors, collect what is owed, close bank accounts and deal with employees.
- Tell HMRC. Settle tax, file final returns and close VAT and PAYE schemes.
- File the application. The directors submit the form to Companies House, with a fee of £13 online.
- Notify interested parties. Within seven days, send copies to creditors, employees, shareholders, directors and pension trustees.
- Wait. Companies House publishes a notice in the Gazette. If nobody objects within two months, the company is struck off, and a second notice confirms it.
The risks
If the company still has assets when it is struck off, they pass to the Crown. Creditors who were not paid can apply to have the company restored to the register, within six years, and pursue it or the directors. Directors who use strike off to avoid paying known debts may face personal liability and disqualification. HMRC can also object to a strike off if it has outstanding matters.
Members' voluntary liquidation
A members' voluntary liquidation, or MVL, is a formal process for solvent companies. It is run by a licensed insolvency practitioner, who collects the assets, pays the debts and distributes the surplus to shareholders.
The process
- The directors make a declaration of solvency, stating that the company can pay its debts within twelve months.
- The shareholders pass a resolution to wind up the company, and appoint the liquidator.
- The liquidator takes control, notifies creditors, deals with HMRC, realises the assets and distributes the surplus.
- When the work is complete, the liquidator files final accounts, and the company is dissolved.
Costs
An MVL costs more than strike off because an insolvency practitioner is involved. Fees vary with the size and complexity of the company. For companies with significant retained profit or assets, the tax benefit can outweigh the cost.
The tax difference
Money that shareholders receive can be taxed as income, as a dividend, or as capital, treated under capital gains rules, and the rate is usually lower for capital.
- In a liquidation, distributions are generally treated as capital, so capital gains tax applies. If the conditions for Business Asset Disposal Relief are met, a reduced rate may apply, subject to a lifetime limit. The rate has been rising in recent years, so check the current figure on GOV.UK.
- On a strike off, distributions of up to £25,000 in total can be treated as capital, in line with HMRC's practice. Above that, the payment is taxed as income, normally as a dividend, at dividend rates.
For a company with reserves above £25,000, an MVL may therefore save tax, even after the liquidator's fee. There are anti-avoidance rules aimed at people who close a company and start a similar business soon after, which would treat the capital distribution as income. These must be considered before choosing a route.
Comparison
| Feature | Strike off | MVL |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Low, with an online fee of £13 | Higher, with a liquidator's fee |
| Time | A few months | Several months or longer |
| Tax treatment | Capital up to £25,000, income above | Capital |
| Suitable for | Small, simple, solvent companies | Companies with assets or reserves above £25,000 |
| Oversight | None beyond the register | A licensed practitioner |
| Risk to directors | Higher if debts are overlooked | Lower, with formal process |
Before you close
- Pay creditors and collect debts
- File final accounts and returns, and pay tax
- Close VAT, PAYE and CIS registrations
- Deal with employees, including redundancy and pension duties
- Distribute or deal with the assets
- Close bank accounts and cancel contracts
- Keep company records for the required period
- Tell Companies House if directors change
If the company is insolvent
If the company cannot pay its debts, directors have duties to creditors and should not carry on trading in a way that makes the position worse. Take advice from an authorised insolvency practitioner. A creditors' voluntary liquidation is the usual route for an orderly close. Using strike off in these circumstances risks personal liability. We do not provide insolvency advice, and will refer you to a licensed practitioner where needed.
A practical example
Consider a one director consultancy with £40,000 of cash left after all debts and taxes are settled. Striking off would treat the first £25,000 of distributions as capital, and the remaining £15,000 as a dividend. A members' voluntary liquidation could treat the whole £40,000 as capital, which may attract a lower rate, particularly if Business Asset Disposal Relief is available. Whether the liquidator's fee is justified depends on the tax difference, so the sums should be run before choosing. A company with only a few thousand pounds left will almost always be better off with strike off.
What we do
We prepare the final accounts and returns, advise on the tax of the closure and compare the options. See closing or striking off companies. For related work on gains, see capital gains tax reporting. For official guidance, see GOV.UK: Close a limited company.
Questions we are asked
The Companies House online fee is £13. Any accountant's fee for final accounts and tax is extra.
Strike off suits small, simple, solvent companies. A members' voluntary liquidation can save tax where reserves exceed £25,000.
Yes, and they can apply to restore the company within six years.
It is not appropriate if the company has debts it cannot pay. Take advice from a licensed insolvency practitioner.
Closing a company?
Tell us about the company's assets and debts and we will send a written proposal for the final accounts and tax work.