What is a Self Assessment tax return?
A plain explanation of the system HMRC uses to collect tax on income it cannot deduct at source.
Self Assessment is the system that HMRC uses to collect Income Tax from people whose income is not fully taxed before they receive it. Instead of your employer deducting tax each pay day, you report your income for the year, HMRC calculates the tax and you pay it. The form you complete is called a tax return. The name makes it sound optional or informal. It is neither. It is a legal declaration, and the numbers are your responsibility.
Why the system exists
Most employees never see it, because PAYE does the work. Your employer deducts tax and National Insurance from every payslip using the tax code HMRC supplies, and pays it over. By the end of the year the right amount has usually been paid, and nothing more is needed.
PAYE cannot cover income that does not pass through a payroll. If you work for yourself, nobody deducts tax from your sales. If you let out a flat, the tenant pays you rent in full. If you own shares, a company pays a dividend without deducting tax from it. In each case, HMRC needs a way to find out what you received and to collect the right amount. Self Assessment is that way.
What the return reports
A return summarises your income and claims for one tax year. Depending on your situation it can include:
| Section | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Employment | Pay, tax deducted and benefits from any jobs |
| Self-employment | Turnover, allowable expenses and profit |
| Property | Rental income and costs |
| Savings and investments | Interest and dividends |
| Pensions and benefits | State Pension, other pensions and taxable benefits |
| Capital gains | Profits on selling assets such as shares or second properties |
| Reliefs | Pension contributions, Gift Aid donations and other reductions |
From these figures HMRC works out your total tax and National Insurance, subtracts any tax already paid, and tells you whether you owe more or are due a repayment.
Who runs it and how it works in practice
HMRC does not usually check the return before accepting it. The principle is that you assess yourself and HMRC may check later. For several years after filing, HMRC can open an enquiry, ask questions and request records. If it finds a careless error, it can charge penalties on the extra tax. That is why keeping records and filing accurate figures matters even if no one reviews the return at the time.
The cycle of a Self Assessment year
The tax year runs from 6 April to 5 April. The return for a given year is due after the year ends:
- 6 April. The new tax year starts and the previous year's return can be filed.
- 31 July. Second payment on account for the year just ended, if you make them.
- 5 October. Last day to register for Self Assessment if this is your first time.
- 31 October. Deadline for paper returns.
- 31 January. Deadline for online returns and for paying the balance, plus the first payment on account for the next year.
You can see that the return arrives many months after the income. That gap is a reason people spend the money before the tax is paid. Setting aside a share of your earnings each month avoids a shock in January.
How Self Assessment differs from PAYE
PAYE taxes you as you earn. Self Assessment taxes you after the year, on what you report. That has three effects:
- You do the arithmetic, or software does. With PAYE, HMRC works out the tax. With Self Assessment, you supply the figures.
- Payments are lumpy. Instead of small deductions each month, you pay larger sums on set dates.
- Responsibility sits with you. If a figure is wrong, you are accountable for it, whoever prepared it.
If you have both employment and self-employment, the two systems run together. PAYE continues for the job, and the return reconciles everything at the end.
People often think the return is for business owners. In practice, many of the people filing are employees with additional income, landlords, company directors with dividends or higher earners with a Child Benefit charge. See who needs to file.
What it costs to get wrong
The most common problems are filing late, paying late and entering figures that do not match the records. Late filing and late payment attract fixed penalties and interest. Figures that are wrong because of carelessness can attract penalties of a percentage of the extra tax. Those percentages are higher where the error was deliberate. Our guide to deadlines and penalties sets them out.
What HMRC does with the return
Once you submit, HMRC records the return and sends your tax calculation to your online account. Its systems then compare the figures with information it already holds from employers, banks, pension providers and other sources. If something does not fit, such as interest reported by a bank that you left off, HMRC may write to you. Most returns pass without any contact. A small number are selected for a closer look, either at random or because a figure appears unusual. Keeping a tidy set of records means that, if a question arrives, you can answer it in a few days instead of searching for papers.
Records and the five year rule
The responsibility to keep records is part of the system. For most people with self-employment or rental income, that means at least five years after the 31 January filing deadline. In practice, keep everything for six years and you will not be caught short. Digital copies of paper receipts are accepted, provided they are legible and complete.
Doing it yourself or using an accountant
HMRC's online service is free and suitable for straightforward returns. People who prefer help usually ask for it because they want the return checked by someone who knows the rules, they have a complicated mix of income, they have missed a deadline or they simply want the job done. If you are weighing it up, read our complete guide and see what our Self Assessment service includes.
For official guidance, see GOV.UK: What is Self Assessment.
Questions we are asked
Self Assessment is the system. The tax return is the form you complete within it.
No. Landlords, directors, higher earners and anyone with income that is not fully taxed at source may need to file.
Not usually before accepting it, but it can open an enquiry later and ask for records.
At least five years after the 31 January deadline for self-employed and landlords, and for a shorter period for other taxpayers.
Not sure whether you need to file?
Tell us how you earn and we will say whether a return is needed and propose the next step if so.