IR35 status check: inside or outside IR35?
How status is decided, who is responsible for the decision and what the tests look at in practice.
IR35, also known as the off-payroll working rules, exists to stop people working like employees while being paid through a company in order to pay less tax and National Insurance. A contractor who works through their own limited company is only taxed as a business if the contract is outside IR35. If it is inside, the payments are taxed much like employment income. The difference can be thousands of pounds a year, which is why status checks matter. This guide explains how status is decided and who is responsible.
The basic question
The question is simple to state. If the contractor had been engaged directly by the client, would they be an employee? If yes, the engagement is inside IR35. If no, it is outside. The answer does not depend on what the contract is called or on whether the contractor has their own company. It depends on how the work is really done.
Who makes the decision
The responsibility depends on the size of the client.
| Client | Who decides status |
|---|---|
| Public sector body | The public body |
| Medium or large private sector client | The client, through a status determination statement |
| Small private sector client | The contractor's own company |
A small company is one that meets at least two of three tests: annual turnover of no more than £15 million, a balance sheet total of no more than £7.5 million, and no more than 50 employees. These thresholds were raised in April 2025. Where the client is medium or large, it must carry out a status assessment, give the contractor a written status determination statement with its reasons, and respond to challenges. If it does not take reasonable care, responsibility for the tax can pass back to the client.
The tests
HMRC and the courts look at a range of factors. None decides the matter alone. The main ones are as follows.
Control
Does the client control how, when and where the work is done? An employee is told what to do and how. A contractor decides how to deliver the result. A contractor who works to their own methods, schedule and tools points outside IR35. A contractor who is told to follow the client's processes, hours and instructions looks more like an employee.
Substitution
Can the contractor send someone else to do the work, at their own expense, without the client's approval? A real right of substitution points outside IR35. A contract that says a substitute is allowed, but the client would never accept one, points the other way. Personal service is a strong indicator of employment.
Mutuality of obligation
Is the client obliged to offer work, and the contractor obliged to accept it? Where there is an ongoing obligation, it points towards employment. Where each engagement stands alone and either side can walk away, it points outside.
Other factors
- Financial risk. A contractor who bears the cost of fixing mistakes and can make a profit or loss on the contract looks more independent.
- Part and parcel of the organisation. Contractors who are integrated into the team, with company email, line managers and management responsibilities, look more like employees.
- Business on own account. Does the contractor have other clients, market their services and use their own equipment?
- Right of dismissal and benefits. Entitlement to paid leave, sick pay or a bonus points towards employment.
CEST, HMRC's tool
HMRC provides an online tool, the Check Employment Status for Tax service, usually called CEST. You answer questions and it returns a result: inside, outside or unable to determine. HMRC says it will stand by the result if the information entered is accurate and the tool is used correctly. It does not consider all factors in every case, so a result that conflicts with the actual working practice may be challenged. Using it is a good first step, not a substitute for thinking about the facts.
An example
Two contractors have the same job title and day rate.
Contractor A works from home for a client, on a project to build a data pipeline. She decides how to build it and when to work, uses her own laptop, can send a colleague from her own company to do part of the work and has two other clients. She is paid on delivery of milestones and will fix defects at her own cost. This looks outside IR35.
Contractor B sits in the client's office five days a week, reports to a manager who allocates his tasks, uses the client's equipment, cannot send a substitute and works only for this client. He is paid a daily rate whether or not a deliverable is finished. This looks inside IR35.
The tax outcome is very different, though both are engaged through limited companies.
Consequences of an inside decision
If the engagement is inside IR35 and the client is medium or large, the client or the agency paying the contractor's company must deduct income tax and employee National Insurance from the payment, as if the contractor were an employee. They must also pay employer National Insurance. The contractor's company then receives the net amount. The company does not then need to apply the old intermediaries rules to the same payment. If the client is small and the contractor's company decides, the company must work out a deemed employment payment at the end of the tax year and pay the tax and National Insurance on it.
Challenging a decision
A contractor who disagrees with a status determination can challenge it. The client must respond within 45 days, either confirming or changing the decision, with reasons. If the contractor is dissatisfied, they can ask for a review, and in the end can go to the tax tribunal if they are charged. Keep evidence of how the work is done, not just the contract.
- A written contract that reflects the real working arrangement
- Records showing that you decide how and when to do the work
- Evidence of your own equipment, insurance and costs
- Invoices to other clients, and marketing materials
- Proof of a real, usable right of substitution
- Records of work you corrected at your own expense
Practical tips
Check status for every engagement, not once for your business. Review it if the working pattern changes, for example when an engagement is extended. Make sure the contract and the reality match. If the client carries out a status determination, ask for the reasons, and compare them with how you work. If you are unsure, take advice before signing.
How we can help
We review contracts and working practices, run status checks, help contractors challenge determinations and advise clients on their responsibilities. See IR35 and contractor support. If you are weighing up how to be paid, see salary versus dividends.
For official guidance, see GOV.UK: Understanding off-payroll working (IR35).
Questions we are asked
A set of rules that tax contractors who work like employees, but are paid through their own company, much like employees.
For public bodies and medium or large private clients, the client. For small private clients, your own company.
HMRC says it will stand by its result if the information is accurate, but it does not capture every factor.
Yes. The client must respond to a challenge within 45 days, and you can take it further if you disagree.
Get your contract status checked
Send us the contract and a description of how you work and we will send a written proposal for a status review.