IR35 review and contractor support
Clear answers on whether a contract is inside or outside IR35, and what that means for your tax.
What IR35 is for
IR35, also known as the off-payroll working rules, exists to make sure that someone who works like an employee, but is engaged through their own company, pays broadly the same tax and National Insurance as an employee would. It is not a ban on contracting. It is a test of whether the working relationship, in reality, looks like employment.
The consequences of getting it wrong can be large: unpaid tax and National Insurance, interest and penalties, sometimes going back several years.
Who decides your status
The responsibility depends on who the client is.
| Client | Who decides status | Who applies the tax if inside IR35 |
|---|---|---|
| Medium or large private sector company, or public body | The client, via a status determination | The fee-payer, which is the client or the agency |
| Small private sector company | The contractor's own company | The contractor's company |
A "small" company for this purpose is determined using Companies Act size tests. This is a crucial point for both contractors and engagers, so we always confirm it first.
What a status review looks at
A proper review looks at the whole picture, not only the contract. The main factors are:
- Personal service: whether you can send a substitute, and whether anyone has ever done so.
- Control: how much the client decides what you do, when and how.
- Mutuality of obligation: whether the client must offer work and you must accept it.
- Financial risk: whether you bear risk, such as fixing mistakes at your own cost.
- Part and parcel: whether you are integrated into the client's organisation as an employee would be.
Written terms matter, but if the real working practice differs from the contract, the practice generally wins.
- The contract and any statements of work
- How work is actually directed and supervised
- Whether a substitute is allowed and has been used
- Equipment, expenses and who carries the cost of poor work
- Evidence of the client's own status determination, if applicable
Outside IR35: what stays the same
If a contract is assessed as outside IR35, the contractor's company can continue to be paid gross and extract profit through a mix of salary and dividends, with normal limited company accounting. Evidence of the assessment should be kept, in case of challenge.
Inside IR35: what changes
If a contract is inside IR35, the fee-payer must deduct income tax and employee National Insurance and pay employer National Insurance, similar to normal employment. The contractor does not usually get the same flexibility to take dividends from that income. We help you model the take-home pay so you can decide whether the contract is worth accepting, and we handle the reporting.
Support for engagers and agencies
If you hire contractors, we can review your status determination process, check that decisions are reasoned and documented, and set up the disagreement process that the rules require. We can also help with the payroll side if you are the fee-payer, using our payroll service.
What contractors should keep
If your status is ever questioned, evidence matters more than opinion. Keep the signed contract, any statement of work and the written determination you received from the client, if there is one. Keep examples showing how the work really happens: who decides how and when it is done, whether you could send a substitute and whether you are part of the client's own team. Responsibility for the status decision sits with the end client in many private sector engagements, but small client companies are generally exempt, so the position varies. Check the current rules for your case.
Scope and timing
IR35 support is described in a written scope of work per contract or as a package. For more on checking status, see our guide to the IR35 status check.
Questions we are asked
It can. The rules apply to workers engaged through intermediaries such as personal service companies. Whether a particular contract is caught depends on the working relationship.
It is a useful starting point, but it has limits, and HMRC has said it will stand by the result only if the information entered is accurate. We prefer a fuller review for important contracts.
Clients covered by the rules must have a process for challenging a status determination. We help you set out your case.
No. Businesses that engage contractors need to understand their own duties, particularly if they are medium or large.
Get clarity on contractor status
Send us a contract and a short description of the work, and we will send a written proposal for a review.